I (36F) have been with my boyfriend (37M) for a little over a year and weāre currently living together.
When we first started dating, I felt like we were generally aligned on wanting marriage and kids. Early in the relationship, he told me that he could see himself being ready for marriage after about two years of dating. While there were never any promises made, that timeline felt compatible with what I wanted for my life.
Over time, though, things seem to have changed. I know I want to get married and start a family relatively soon. At 36, I feel a sense of urgency about making decisions that move my life forward. My boyfriend is now planning to go back to school and pursue a new career path, and he has told me he likely would not be ready for marriage until he finishes his program, which would be another 3ā4 years from now.
What makes this difficult is that heās a genuinely good person. This is actually the healthiest and most stable relationship Iāve been in. We get along well, rarely have major conflicts, and I care about him deeply. Because of that, I donāt want to walk away from something good simply because Iām anxious about timelines.
At the same time, Iām struggling with the fact that the timeline I thought we were working toward has changed significantly. Another factor is that he has seen a lot of divorces and unhappy marriages in his family and among people close to him. Because of those experiences, he has expressed that he doesnāt really believe marriage works long term for most people and has questioned whether it makes sense at all. While he hasnāt said he never wants to get married, those comments have made me wonder whether his hesitation is really about timing or whether he has deeper doubts about marriage itself.
I also canāt ignore that before me, he had not been in a serious relationship for about seven years. During that time, he mostly dated casually and never got particularly close to marriage with anyone. Part of me wonders if thatās simply because he hadnāt met the right person yet, while another part of me wonders whether it reflects a broader pattern of being uncomfortable with long-term commitment.
I often feel like Iām the one initiating conversations about our relationship. I donāt want to pressure someone into a timeline theyāre not comfortable with. But I also donāt want to wake up at 40 in the exact same place I am now when I could be married with kids by then with someone who is actually ready.
Part of me wonders if my anxiety is being driven by my age and fear of running out of time. Another part of me worries that when someone goes from saying they could see marriage after two years of dating to saying they wonāt be ready for another 3ā4 years, while also expressing doubts that marriage works long term and having spent years avoiding serious relationships, thatās important information I shouldnāt ignore.
For those who have been in similar situations, how do you tell the difference between a partner who genuinely wants a future with you but whose timeline has changed versus a partner who is slowly moving the goalposts because theyāre not sure they want marriage at all?
Would a shift like this be a dealbreaker for you?